Cultured Meat Needs a Race to Mission, Not a Race to Market
A much needed call to action for cultured meat developers to to course-correct toward a mission-driven mindset
2022
In October 2022, Nature Food published a special issue on cellular agriculture, including a timely call to action for the cultured meat field co-authored by New Harvest.
RACE TO MISSION
Overview
As excitement builds toward cultured meat (CM) reaching more markets, at lower costs, and with more accurate flavors and textures, we have to take a deep breath and remember that commercial success is simply not enough.
The benefits popularly ascribed to cultured meat are not inherent to the technology. We could have great tasting, cheap, and readily available cultured meat products that continue to rely on animal slaughter and generate much the same outcomes for personal and environmental health as traditional meat.
In short, a race-to-market mindset could drive developers to cut corners in ways that slow progress or lead us back to where we started.
Keeping cultured meat development on point, and avoiding detrimental short-cuts, means accepting core mission objectives as crucial, and maintaining a race-to-mission mindset.
Towards this goal, New Harvest has co-authored a piece just published by Nature Food, describing what a race to mission entails. This includes five parameters that represent base mission objectives as well as minimal states of technological readiness for CM developers: slaughter-free solutions, health & safety, proactive sustainability, scale for impact (not just cost), and open science.
It is a call to action, explaining how these parameters can be pursued in a way that speeds progress and sets the highest standards for the field.
RACE TO MISSION
A Note on Open Access
It was a challenge for New Harvest to uphold its commitment to open access while publishing in Nature Food. It was the ongoing challenge faced by many publishing researchers: do you go for impact factor and traditional institutional recognition, or open access? Furthermore, the article itself touts the importance of open science.
In the end we felt that the ideas in this paper warranted highlighting in a major journal that would be read by a community more wide-reaching than those in cellular agriculture, and we were assured by editors that the article would be openly accessible for the first month.
Authors also have access to a special open access link to share the article as well.
While this article was being written, we have also made progress on our own policies with respect to open access publishing. In the future we aim to avoid these types of scenarios where our calls to action for open are compromised by working within closed systems.
RACE TO MISSION
Outcomes
The peer-reviewed comment, Cultured meat needs a race to mission, not a race to market is published in Nature Food.
Nature Food publishes a special issue “Focus on cellular agriculture” in October 2022.
A webinar on the special issue, featuring two authors on the paper, discusses how cellular agriculture technologies can benefit or hinder sustainable food system transformations.
RACE TO MISSION
Progress Timeline
Jan 2022 - New Harvest is invited to contribute to a special issue of Nature Food focused on cellular agriculture.
Oct 2022 - Our article, Cultured Meat Needs a Race to Mission, Not a Race to Market is published.
Oct 2022 - Nature Food holds a webinar in support of the special issue, moderated by Annisa Chand, Senior Editor Nature Food, including two authors from our article (Dwayne Holmes & David Humbird), as well as Garrett Broad, and Marianne Ellis.
RACE TO MISSION
Collaborators
The article was authored by Dwayne Holmes, David Humbird, Jan Dutkiewicz, Yadira Tejeda-Saldana, Breanna Duffy and Isha Datar.
RACE TO MISSION
Funders
This work was funded by New Harvest, through unrestricted donations from our giving community.
Volunteers who were generous with their time contributed to the writing of the text.
RACE TO MISSION
Contact
If you have questions or would like to get in touch regarding this project, please contact info@new-harvest.org